FeynFacet

Proton–proton collisions

Single-inclusive parton production $a\,b\to c+X$ at NLO in the 16 tagged channel classes, for the spin average (UU) and the helicity difference of the incoming partons (LL).

Born diagram 1 of 1 of q q' → q q' (channel class 1, q qp -> q).
Born diagram 1 of 1 of q q' → q q' (channel class 1, q qp -> q).
Born diagram 1 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 1 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 2 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 2 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 3 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 3 of 3 of q g → q g (channel class 13, q g -> q).
Born diagram 1 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 1 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 2 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 2 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 3 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 3 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 4 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Born diagram 4 of 4 of g g → g g (channel class 15, g g -> g).
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 1 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 1 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 13 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 13 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 15 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 15 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 16 of 25.
Real emission g g → g g g (channel class 15): diagram 16 of 25.

What is computed

For a measured parton of momentum $p$ the partonic cross section $\sigma = s\,E\,d\sigma/d^3p$ is written in $v = 1 + t/s$ and $w = -u/(s+t)$, with $s=(k_a+k_b)^2$, $t=(k_a-p)^2$, $u=(k_b-p)^2$ for incoming partons of momenta $k_a$, $k_b$ and $0 < v,w < 1$:

$$\sigma = \sigma_{\rm Born}\,\delta(1-w) + P(v,w)\,c_{\rm reg}(v,w) + P(v,1)\big[c_{0}(v)\,\big[\tfrac{1}{1-w}\big]_+ + c_{1}(v)\,\big[\tfrac{\ln(1-w)}{1-w}\big]_+ + c_{\delta}(v)\,\delta(1-w)\big],$$

Here $\sigma_{\rm Born}$ is the lowest-order term, and $c_{\rm reg}$, $c_0$, $c_1$, $c_\delta$ are the coefficients $R$, $B$, $C$, $A$ of the paper, with $P$ its normalization $\mathcal N$. The scales enter through $L_R=\ln(\mu_R^2/s)$, $L_F=\ln(\mu_F^2/s)$ for the incoming partons and $L_{FF}=\ln(\mu_{FF}^2/s)$ for the fragmenting one ($\mu_{FF}$ is the $\mu_F'$ of the paper).

Here $P = \alpha_s^3/(\pi s v w)$. The fragmenting parton $c$ is unpolarized; the helicity difference is $\tfrac12[\sigma(++)-\sigma(+-)]$, in the HVBM scheme with the finite term $-(\alpha_s/2\pi)\Delta f_{qq}\otimes\sigma_{LL}^{(0)}$ on each polarized incoming quark or antiquark (see Method). Classes 2, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10 start at order $\alpha_s^3$ (no Born term).

The calculation

Step 1 generates the Born, virtual (one-loop) and real-emission diagrams with FeynArts. Step 2 squares them in the three routes; for $g\,g\to g\,g\,g$ (25 diagrams, 325 products), every amplitude is simplified once with the transversality conditions of the gluon polarizations, color is separated and each color network evaluated once, only the products $i\le j$ are formed, gluon polarization sums are applied one gluon at a time, and the products run in parallel. Step 3 maps the real emission onto six reverse-unitarity families and the virtual graphs onto three box families, reduces them with Kira, and evaluates the masters with SubTropica. Steps 4 and 5 expand at threshold, renormalize, subtract the collinear singularities of both incoming partons and the fragmenting one, and compare with the reference codes.

Checks

ClassProcessUU vs Aversa et al.LL vs Jäger et al.FeynCalc = FORM = Tracer
1$q\,q'\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
2$q\,q'\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
3$q\,\bar q'\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
4$q\,\bar q'\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
5$q\,\bar q\to q'$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
6$q\,q\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
7$q\,q\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
8$q\,g\to q'$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
9$q\,g\to \bar q'$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
10$q\,g\to \bar q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
11$q\,\bar q\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
12$q\,\bar q\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
13$q\,g\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
14$q\,g\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
15$g\,g\to g$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)
16$g\,g\to q$agreesagreesagree (2 random exact points)

The reference codes were evaluated at nine points per class; all four coefficients agree to the precision of the double-precision reference values ($10^{-15}$ to $2\cdot10^{-7}$). Inside the notebooks: double and single poles cancel, the Born squares equal the Born table, for selected classes the real-emission squares do not depend on the gluon reference vectors, and the squares of the three routes agree (exact arithmetic at two random rational points).

The regular coefficient $c_{\rm reg}(v=0.5,w)$ for the classes 1 ($q\,q'\to q$), 13 ($q\,g\to q$), 15 ($g\,g\to g$) and 16 ($g\,g\to q$); spin average (left) and helicity difference (right).  $N_c=3$, $N_f=5$, all scales $\sqrt s$.
The regular coefficient $c_{\rm reg}(v=0.5,w)$ for the classes 1 ($q\,q'\to q$), 13 ($q\,g\to q$), 15 ($g\,g\to g$) and 16 ($g\,g\to q$); spin average (left) and helicity difference (right). $N_c=3$, $N_f=5$, all scales $\sqrt s$.
The coefficients of $[1/(1-w)]_+$, $[\ln(1-w)/(1-w)]_+$ and $\delta(1-w)$ as functions of $v$, same classes; spin average solid, helicity difference dashed.  For $g\,g\to q$ the three are exactly opposite for the two spin cases, as are the Born terms.
The coefficients of $[1/(1-w)]_+$, $[\ln(1-w)/(1-w)]_+$ and $\delta(1-w)$ as functions of $v$, same classes; spin average solid, helicity difference dashed. For $g\,g\to q$ the three are exactly opposite for the two spin cases, as are the Born terms.

Files

Notebooks: Processes/Hadronic. Coefficients: Coefficients/ProtonProton.wl.

python3 Coefficients/evaluate.py pp 13 LL 0.3 0.2 --digits 30